Legend · c. 1632
Lobster Cove & Crab Point
Dixie Bull investigation zone
[L]Legend / Oral Tradition43.64360° N, 70.20720° W
In layers05 · Legends & Lost Cushing

Historical significance
Casco Bay folklore places the pirate Dixie Bull along these channel-facing coves in the early 1630s. No verified evidence of buried treasure on Cushing exists.
On the ground
- West-facing coves offer concealment from Portland approaches.
- Ledges provide natural landings independent of tide.
Open research questions
- 1.Would a pirate realistically choose Cushing over the outer islands?
- 2.What would evidence — not treasure — actually look like?
From the archive
People associated with this place
Where to walk next
Distances are straight-line from recorded coordinates. Island roads curve, so allow more time than the estimate.
How we know
Continue the trail
- 01Stand at Levett's Cellar & Spicer's CovePlace · Levett's Cellar & Spicer's Cove — Colonial · 1623
- 02Look at the evidence: Plan of Cushing IslandSource · Plan of Cushing Island — ca. 1888 · Maine Memory Network / Maine Historical Society
- 03Who was Michael Mitton?Person · Michael Mitton — Third English owner; Casco Bay's mermaid witness
- 04Open the case file: The Dixie Bull LegendCase file · The Dixie Bull Legend — Case file V
- 05Read the whole layer: Legends & Lost CushingLayer · Legends & Lost Cushing — Layer 05 · All eras